"I needed love. I needed support. I needed somebody to hear me out and not just tell me what I wanted to hear."

Chloe Cole on her life trajectory: puberty blockers at 13; double mastectomy at 15; detransition advocate at 18

54
16

Chloe Cole socially transitioned at the age of 12, went on puberty blockers at 13, and had a “gender-affirming” double mastectomy at 15. She passed so successfully as a boy that most of her peers at school did not know she was transgender. While watching a video in class about Harlow’s studies of rhesus monkeys, which demonstrated the importance of the maternal bond to proper infant psychological development, she began to think about herself in relation to maternity for the very first time. She began to fear that she had perhaps already sterilized herself through the combination of puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones that she began in early adolescence. She felt regret that she would never be able to breastfeed an infant. Thus began the unraveling her transgender identification, which turned out to be the fleeting enthusiasm of a troubled and impressionable child exposed to seductive images broadcast by Instagram influencers. With the aid of an affirming psychologist, endocrinologist, and surgeon, she inflicted permanent harms on her body that clinicians who had taken an oath to do no harm assured her was a necessary form of life-saving care for the person — the boy — she really was all along. Online trans communities convinced her that dosing herself with powerful controlled substances and slicing off her breasts would reveal her true self. Gender clinicians extracted her parent’s consent through an act of emotional blackmail: “Would you like a dead daughter or a live son?”

At 18, she has become a public advocate traveling the country and asserting the fundamental incapacity of children to make the risky and life-altering choice entailed in gender reassignment, showing remarkable poise while speaking in front of various state legislatures and government entities. She has also founded an organization called Detrans United. The letter with which the organization announced its founding, addressed to Attorney General Merrick Garland, in response to a prior letter signed by the American Academy of Pediatrics calling for the investigation of critics of pediatric transition, is an eloquent appeal by which no reasonable reader can fail to be persuaded.

Full transcript of our conversation follows.

SUMMARY KEYWORDS

transition, people, parents, blockers, kids, long, realized, testosterone, feel, months, speaking, mastectomy, started, several years, allowed, real, transgender, thinking, infants, testify

SPEAKERS

Wesley Yang, Chloe Cole

Chloe Cole

So my name is Chloe Cole and I am an 18 year old former transgender kid. I'm from the Central Valley area of California, so I am from here. I was transitioning between the ages of 12 to 16. I was medically transitioned for about three years. And… I came to realize that I was damaging not only my physical health by transitioning and impeding my own natural development, I also realized that it was it was a threat to my mental health, and that there were underlying traumas and comorbidities that led to me developing dysphoria.

And I also realized that this was — I wasn't really equipped then to make this kind of decision. I mean, at 13, I was allowed to go on blockers and testosterone. At 15, I actually, I got a double mastectomy, meaning that both of my breasts were removed. And I really don't think that this is a decision that kids should be allowed to make.

I don't really have much of a problem with adults who are fully informed and fully developed making this decision. But it's, it's not for kids. And that's why I'm here.

Wesley Yang

So can you talk about how you first came to believe that you were a boy?

Chloe Cole

There were a lot of factors, but I think the biggest one was ultimately social media. I don't think I would’ve even have had this idea were it not for that.

Wesley Yang

So how old were you when you got a phone.

Chloe Cole

I was 11 when I got my first phone and started using social media. My first social media app was Instagram. And almost immediately after making an account, I was exposed to a lot of LGBTQ content. And it was it was almost always trans-identified teens between the ages of 12 to 19. And there was always kids who were female to male. So they were “trans-boys”, as they call themselves.

Wesley Yang

Who were the, like, main influencers that you really…

Chloe Cole

I wouldn't really say it was like a specific influencer, it was just like these smaller accounts usually run by groups, and seeing he little communities they had, and that people really seemed to love them, and they would they would always stick up for them. I mean, I was I was kind of like an odd one out among my peers so that I struggled a lot socially growing up. I didn't realize at the time, but that was something that for a long time I really wished I had for myself.

Wesley Yang

Had you been tomboy?

Chloe Cole

Yeah. I mean, I was actually quite a feminine kid. But as I got older, I started developing more like tomboyish tendencies.

Wesley Yang

So you were not long after getting a phone and being on Instagram, you were immediately attracted to… How did you think and feel about it?

Chloe Cole

I mean…

Wesley Yang

It seemed cool.

Chloe Cole

Yeah. And it was just such a novel thing to me. And like, it, it just, it just made sense that this was what I was, and that I was kind of given the impression that I would by transitioning, I would become my real self as a boy and and so that I would be happier and more whole as a person.

Wesley Yang

When did you tell yourself ‘I'm a boy’? When did you tell other people also…

Chloe Cole

I was 12 when I first started transitioning, I first came out to like some friends my older sister, and then down the line eventually to my parents.

Wesley Yang

How did they respond?

Chloe Cole

My parents? They were supportive, but they didn't exactly know what to do, because they're, I mean — it was such a new thing.

Wesley Yang

What year was this?

Chloe Cole

2017.

And so they wanted some support with this. And so they sent me to a therapist…

Female Passerby

What you rather have these kids kill themselves? Teenagers killing themselves?

Chloe Cole

[At passerby] I was one of those kids!

Wesley Yang

So your parents wanted to help you do this?

Chloe Cole

yeah. The therapist was basically like, ‘Okay, you're a boy…’ there's there wasn't really a very thorough process. But they basically coerced my parents into it. They gave them the whole ‘transgender adolescents are at a high risk of suicide if they're not affirmed..so would you rather have like a, a dead daughter or a live, son?’ That's kind of the gist of it.

Wesley Yang

Did you feel like you would kill yourself?

Chloe Cole

No it actually wasn't until I was about two years on testosterone that I I started feeling suicidal.

Wesley Yang

So we put you first on blockers and immediately on.

Chloe Cole

Yeah, it was about a month long period.

Wesley Yang

So now long were you on? You were only on blockers for a month/

Chloe Cole

I was on them for about a year or so. But I was on testosterone for about three years. Three years. Yeah.

Wesley Yang

What was that, like, at first and then later?

Chloe Cole

You mean like, in terms of like, the physical?

Wesley Yang

What did it feel like? emotionally physically?

For the period that I was on blockers alone, I just felt kind of bored. And like a tiny bit depressed. I didn't have any sex hormones circulating in my body. So it's hard to describe. I would wake up every day just like waiting for the next best thing. And I actually started to get physical side effects from taking blockers as well, that went away after I stopped them. Namely hot flashes. Usually women who are going through menopause like ages, like 60-70 and so on, get those. It was pretty awful. It would get to the point that it would make my whole body itchy. And I wouldn't be able to wear sweaters or pants during during the cold seasons, because I just it was it was too hot. It was too itchy. I mean, they've got kids on these for several years alone with no supplemental hormones. And I just can't imagine like having to go through that for several years.

But once I served on testosterone saucer, it was almost kind of like a euphoric feeling. I had a lot more energy, I found that I was I was a lot more... at the time, I felt a lot more happy that I was starting to become to become my real self… But I found that as time went on the whole euphoria thing started to go away. There was a honeymoon period, basically. And I started to become disillusioned to the actual experience of being male. And I learned that I wasn't really able to take on that kind of responsibility as a woman.

Wesley Yang

Did you pass pretty well?

Chloe Cole:

Yeah, I did, actually.

Wesley Yang

So as far as the world was concerned, you really were a boy.

Chloe Cole

Yes, most people at school didn't know I was transgender, except for people that I went to elementary or middle school with. And I've been outed behind my back a few times. But very still very few people knew.

Wesley Yang

So the doctors just gave you hormones right away. They didn’t ask you about depression or co-morbidities of other things.

Chloe Cole

It was so long ago that it's kind of difficult to remember the whole process, but I don’t remember it being very thorough. It wasn't until several years later, actually that I got a diagnosis for depression, anxiety and then after I transitioned, it was it was autism and body dysmorphia. So for several years that all went undiagnosed. And I feel like if anything that transition and especially — the hormones, the treatments made, ultimately made me feel worse.

Wesley Yang

So when did it start taking another turn

Wesley Yang

But you were still euphoric and into the testosterone when you got the double mastectomy? How did that happen?

Chloe Cole

So double mastectomy, I would say it was only about six months time between my first consultation and actually going under the knife. It as very quick. There was no real vetting, there was no…

Wesley Yang

it was a clinic which was in..

Chloe Cole

Oakland. Kaiser in Oakland. There was there was no like, yeah, yeah. But there was there was no like, I wasn't given like a psychiatric evaluation

Wesley Yang

you felt at that time? Yeah.

I don't know. Okay, they are the kids. I know and they also trying to get in the face of women, man.

Wesley Yang How did you feel?

Chloe Cole

I would say there was another shorter honeymoon period. But that quickly went away once I had to like deal with the whole mess post-op. And I mean, I was basically disabled for a while/ I couldn't lift my arms like over and over my head for maybe, I think the time period was like three to four months. And I was given the impression that it would, I would be fully healed over or at least mostly, by maybe like nine to 12 months. I'm still dealing with complications two years later, more than two years later, actually.

Wesley Yang

You’re still getting infected?

Chloe Cole

Yeah. I'm actually not exactly sure what it was. I haven't been getting any real help with it. My surgeon actually gave me advice that temporarily made it worse. So I can't really rely on my healthcare provider anymore to help me because

Chloe Cole

Well, I was given the impression that, that complications usually happened within like the first year, but it's been going on for well over two years.

Wesley Yang

So how long after that did you start thinking…

Chloe Cole

I would say the grief came within the first two months, but I couldn't really identify the feeling because like, I mean — I was several years in the transition…I already look like a like a boy…

Wesley Yang

You were fully committed…

Chloe Cole

Yeah. And it was it was hard just to fathom that it could be the wrong thing because I I was in it for so long and everybody around me was was too. So I had a fear of being wrong, actually. And I was like, now that I look back on it….

Wesley Yang

How many of your friends were trans?

Chloe Cole

I knew a few people at school who identified as like non-binary or bisexual…stuff like that. I had one friend actually who was female to male as well never like physically transitioned, but he's socially transitioned…

Wesley Yang

So the school and your friends immediately affirmed you and everything?

Chloe Cole

Yeah, the school there wasn't really any pushback. I wouldn't really say like, they pushed me into it, but, they allowed me to, change my name to files with my parents.

I mean, a lot of people say that there's like a lot of like, there's a lot of schools now that are hiding from parents that their child is transgender and that like they're teaching like, queer theory in schools? Yeah, that was never really my experience. I mean, I live in a relatively conservative area of California. And I don't know if things are changing now. I just graduated this year from high school.

Wesley Yang

But 15 is, you know, it's quite shocking. And you have people over there claiming that it doesn't happen.

Chloe Cole

Oh, it happens. And I'm not an isolated case either. This happens all the time.

Wesley Yang

It happened to you. When did you start thinking, I regret this?

Chloe Cole

I think the biggest catalyst for realizing that this was all a mistake was when I was taking a psychology class my junior year. I had a lesson on the Harlow experiments with monkey infants. Are you familiar with that? So it's basically like, it studies the bond between infant and mother and the importance of that as well as physical affection and breastfeeding, how that plays a in child development. And it does that using on rhesus monkey infants and surrogate mothers made of bit of cloth and wire. This was the first time that I had really ever thought of maternity and how that might look for me.

And I realized that, well, not only might I be infertile from these treatments, but even if I end up being able to carry a healthy baby to term, I'll never be able to breastfeed. I'll never be able to have that bonding experience or give my baby…go the natural route with my child. I don't even have that. I don't have that option anymore because I made an adult decision at 15 years. I was only in my mid teens.

The whole trajectory trajectory of my life has been changed because of it.

Wesley Yang

Were you intended to have a hysterectomy?

Chloe Cole

No, no, no. Even while I was in it, I knew it wasn't worth it. Like I knew that. I didn't know if I wanted to have kids one day, but I wanted to preserve, at least slightly, that that that option for myself…

Wesley Yang

After being on testosterone for certain amount of time, you have to — right?

Chloe Cole

Yeah, because of the risk of atrophy, and eventually, your risk of infection or sepsis goes goes up as time goes on. I actually didn't know this.

Wesley Yang

So you went from transition to detransition to becoming quite open and being an activist about detransition.

Chloe Cole

It wasn't easy. At first, actually on my personal social media when I first started expressing that — even just that I regretted my transition, I got a lot of crap for that. A lot of people would tell me ‘it's all your fault. You did this to yourself, you should just shut up! Just stop speaking about this because you're making other people uncomfortable. You're not helping anybody!’ And some people say ‘you don't deserve parents like that; clearly, they loved you and they cared about you. You didn't deserve that testosterone or the top surgery, the mastectomy. But I guess that's true. Kids deserve better.

Wesley Yang

And then how did you end up testifying?

Chloe Cole

Um, so it wasn't until early this year that I started speaking out. The only platform I I have right now is Twitter. But I started speaking out on Twitter, and getting getting getting some interviews. And I've had a few I've had a few groups reach out to me actually, starting with Partners for Ethical Care. They're the first group to fly me out. Actually. They they wanted me to testify against a bill in Louisiana. And I mean, it was a pretty crazy idea at the time. I was still minor. I was still 17. So I had to like, have my parents agree to the whole thing. And I'm so thankful they did. This has been amazing. It's an honor to be able to do this.

Wesley Yang

You hear from a lot of detrans or questioning kids now?

Chloe Cole

kids now. I mostly have like, I mostly have parents and concerned adults reaching out to me. Yeah, but I've started to have desisters abd detransitioners reach out to me over time. And actually a few weeks ago, I had the first former trans kid, reach out to me somebody in in a similar situation to me.

Wesley Yang

Is there a detrans TikTok? Are there influencers who are starting to emerge? On social media? Who are you?

Chloe Cole

I mean, you could say that. Like Helena Kushner, and Watson, right? Because they're two names I can think of…

Wesley Yang

What message do you have to 11-12 year old kids who are watching?

Chloe Cole

Well, I know it's — when you're so young, it's difficult to really think about the future. What you think you might want right now, might not be what you need right now or in the future. Don't surround yourself just with people who will affirm you. Surround yourself with people who are diverse in thought and will say what they think you need to hear even if you don't — even if it's not what you what you want to hear. Because it might be what you need to hear.

Wesley Yang

So your parents supported your transition. They also supported your detransition. Kind of unusual, right? People would say ‘well the system worked,” right, because it gave you what you wanted when you wanted it. And then when you stopped wanting it…

Chloe Cole

It was what I wanted at the time, but it was not what I needed.

Wesley Yang

And what did you need?

Chloe Cole

I needed love. I needed support. I needed somebody to hear me out and not just tell me what I wanted to hear. I needed real support. I needed real psychiatric care and not these experimental treatments that I was put.

Wesley Yang

Did your parents fail you by just affirming?

Chloe Cole

I mean, it was.

Wesley Yang

They were under a lot of pressure.

Chloe Cole

Yeah. It was the one that was really the only choice that were given…

Wesley Yang

So when the clinician said ‘Do you want to have a live son or a dead daughter..".”

Chloe Cole

They guilted them until allowing it.

Wesley Yang

They had no, they didn't have any… they believed it…

Chloe Cole

They had some…they were they were concerned at first, but they basically — the doctors, the therapists, all the medical professionals involved, they basically manipulate the parents into allowing this.

Wesley Yang

Did you also want to manipulate your parents?

Chloe Cole

No.

Wesley Yang

Did you want to pressure them into doing this along with your providers? But you wanted to do it?

Chloe Cole

I wanted to transition, but I didn't want to…

Wesley Yang

If they had said no, you're not. You're not a boy. And we're not going to do this. Would you have not transitioned?

Chloe Cole

I would have been very upset for a while. But I mean, I just — who knows? I mean, who knows what could have happened?

Wesley Yang

Do you think you could have been dissuaded? If they had taken a stand?

Chloe Cole

Probably. They were given such skewed information at the time. And at that time, there weren't detransitioners or anybody really speaking out against this. Right? It was all it was all affirmative.

Wesley Yang

So how much of a difference do you think you can make?

Chloe Cole

I can make a big difference by by speaking.

Wesley Yang

I mean, you're up against the president United States, the American Association of Pediatrics, the Endocrine Society, many billionaires, the consensus within academia all creating a world conditioning us to think it's good to affirm and it's hateful bigotry not to. That’s what you’re up against.

Chloe Cole

Yeah. It's a pretty tough situation. But there's more and more people speaking out every day, including desisters and detransitioners. The people who are affected by this. So it's inevitable that change is going to come